Lincoln and three members of his cabinet (Secretary of State William H. Seward, Attorney General Edward Bates, and Postmaster General William Dennison) attended Taney's memorial service in Washington. [44] Many Republicans accused Taney of being part of a conspiracy to legalize slavery throughout the United States. Level. FILE – In this March 9, 2020, file photo a marble bust of Chief Justice Roger Taney is displayed in the Old Supreme Court Chamber in the U.S. Capitol in Washington. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. [59], President Lincoln made no public statement in response to Taney's death. Suing under the 1845 act that extended admiralty jurisdiction to the Great Lakes, the owners of the Cuba alleged that the negligence of the Genesee Chief caused the accident. FILE - In this March 9, 2020 file photo, a marble bust of Chief Justice Roger Taney is displayed in the Old Supreme Court Chamber in the U.S. Capitol in Washington. That suspension allowed military officials to arrest and imprison suspected secessionists for an indefinite period and without a judicial hearing. [53] An adverse Supreme Court decision would strike a major blow against Lincoln's prosecution of the war, since the blockade cut off the crucial Confederate cotton trade with European countries. [32] Taney wrote the majority opinion in the 1851 case of Strader v. Graham, in which the Court held that slaves from Kentucky who had conducted a musical performance in the free state of Ohio remained slaves because they had voluntarily returned to Kentucky. Rinehart had previously made a much-admired bronze, life-size figure of Taney for the statehouse at Annapolis, Maryland, which was unveiled in 1872. 11.6 Roger B. Taney, Dred Scott v. Sanford Vanessa Valenzuela & Brianna Beas Period. He served as chief justice for 28 years, 198 days, the second longest tenure of any chief justice,[56] and was the oldest ever serving Chief Justice in United States history. "[72] Taney's mixed legacy was noted by Justice Antonin Scalia in his dissenting opinion in Planned Parenthood v. Casey: There comes vividly to mind a portrait by Emanuel Leutze that hangs in the Harvard Law School: Roger Brooke Taney, painted in 1859, the 82nd year of his life, the 24th of his Chief Justiceship, the second after his opinion in Dred Scott. However, in the Briscoe case, the Court upheld the issuance of circulating notes by a state-chartered bank even when the Bank's stock, funds, and profits belonged to the state, and where the officers and directors were appointed by the state legislature. Roger Taney Statue Removed From Maryland State House The statue of Roger B. Taney was lifted away by a crane at about 2 a.m. APUSH Chapter 14 Vocabulary; Shared Flashcard Set. He was born on March 17, 1777 and received a basic education from many private tutors. In 1785, the legislature of Massachusetts had chartered a company to build the Charles River Bridge on the Charles River. Chief Justice Roger B. Taney’s declared that, “while the rights of private property are sacredly guarded, we must not forget, that the community also have rights, and that the happiness and well-being of every citizen depends on their faithful preservation”, justifying. Jocz Production: Jacksonian America Video Review Jackson Era Review apush-chapter-9-outline Vocab: Andrew Jackson, Anti-Masonry, Aroostook War, bank War, Caroline Affair, Daniel Webster, Dorr Rebellion, "Five Civilized Tribes", Indian Territory, John C. calhoun, John Tyler, Martin Van Buren, Nicholas Biddle, Nullification, Panic of 1837, Removal Act, Roger B. Taney, Seminole … Taney ruled that the admiralty jurisdiction of the US Courts extends to waters, which are actually navigable, without regard to the flow of the ocean tides. To the dismay of states' rights advocates, the Marshall Court's rulings in cases such as McCulloch v. Maryland had upheld the power of federal law and institutions over state governments. The House will vote on whether to remove from the U.S. Capitol a bust of Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, the author of the 1857 Dred Scott decision that declared African Americans couldn’t be citizens. Accessed on November 28, 2013. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Stephen_A_Douglas_-_headshot.jpg, “File:SADouglas.jpg.” Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. [43] Rather than removing slavery as an issue, it bolstered the popularity of the anti-slavery Republican Party. 9487), is a well-known and controversial U.S. federal court case that arose out of the American Civil War. The decision was 7 to 2. It was lowered into a truck and driven away to storage. The reputation of Chief Justice Taney can afford to have anything known that he ever did and still leave a great fund of honor and praise to illustrate his name. At the time, Roger B. Taney was the Justice of the Court. The House has approved a bill to remove statues of Gen. Robert E. Lee and other Confederate leaders from the U.S. Capitol, as a reckoning over racial injustice continues following the police killing of George Floyd, a Black man, in Minneapolis. He is all in black, sitting in a shadowed red armchair, left hand resting upon a pad of paper in his lap, right hand hanging limply, almost lifelessly, beside the inner arm of the chair. 5 Dred Scott Roger B. Taney Hippos H: In 1857 Roger B. Taney, the Chief Justice of the United States made it clear that African-Americans had no legal say in American courts. [6] Taney supported Andrew Jackson in the 1824 presidential election and the 1828 presidential election. Roger B. Taney. He strongly disagreed with President Abraham Lincoln's broader interpretation of executive power in the American Civil War. Jackson had Secretary of the Treasury Roger B. Taney withdraw the government’s gold from the Second Bank and deposit it in state “pet” banks. In one advisory opinion that he wrote for the president, Taney argued that the protections of the United States Constitution did not apply to free blacks; he would revisit this issue later in his career. The Jacksonian Democrats were guardians of economic democracy for the “common man”. ... Roger B. Taney: Definition. Not an easy act to follow. The Decision. Accessed on December 22, 2013. After the Baltimore riot of 1861, Union officials arrested state legislator John Merryman, whom they suspected of having destroyed Union infrastructure. Reflecting these hopes, Buchanan's March 4, 1857 inaugural address indicated that the issue of slavery would soon be "finally settled" by the Court. Taney's ancestor, Michael Taney I, had settled in Maryland from England in 1660. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. He ruled that slaves were no different than property and therefore, Scott’s rights were not being violated. It held that the Constitutional prohibition against state laws that would emancipate any "person held to service or labor in [another] state" barred Pennsylvania from punishing a Maryland man who had seized a former slave and her child, and had taken them back to Maryland without seeking an order from the Pennsylvania courts permitting the abduction. The propeller of the boat, Genesee Chief, struck and sank the schooner, Cuba. Sanford, Election of 1858, Election of 1860, Freeport Doctrine, Illinois Senate Race, Lincoln-Douglas Debates, Review, Roger B. Taney, Roger Taney, Stephen Douglas, US History Leave a reply APUSH American Pageant Chapter 19 Review Video – YouTube The attorney for Massachusetts, Simon Greenleaf, challenged Webster's interpretation of the charter, noting that the charter did not explicitly grant a monopoly to the proprietors of the Charles River Bridge. Mayor of the City of New York v. Miln, 36 U.S. 102 (1837). According to the Supreme Court, segregation was fine as long as it was "separate but equal." Early Life. In the past the house the property interpreted the life of Taney and his wife Anne Key (sister of Francis Scott Key), as well as various aspects of life in early nineteenth century Frederick County". The Court narrowly defined a bill of credit as a note issued by the state, on the faith of the state, and designed to circulate as money. [36] In 1846, Dred Scott, an enslaved African-American man living in the slave state of Missouri, had filed suit against his master for his own freedom. John C. Calhoun VP under Jackson who advocated nullification as a measure to protect states from the tyranny of Federal government. On May 27, 1861, Chief Justice Roger B. Taney of Maryland issues Ex parte Merryman, challenging the authority of President Abraham Lincoln and the U.S. military ... b. Roger Brooke Taney (/ ˈ t ɔː n i /; March 17, 1777 – October 12, 1864) was the fifth Chief Justice of the United States, holding that office from 1836 until his death in 1864.He delivered the majority opinion in Dred Scott v.Sandford (1857), ruling that African Americans could not be considered citizens and that Congress could not prohibit slavery in the territories of the United States. Breckinridge. In 1826, Taney and Daniel Webster represented merchant Solomon Etting in a case that appeared before the Supreme Court of the United States. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Surely the framers had in mind banning only notes issued directly by treasuries or land offices. The statue of Roger B. Taney was lifted away by a crane at about 2 a.m. 7573[80]) also created a "process to obtain a bust of Marshall ... and place it there within a minimum of two years. Please leave comments and tell your friends. [57] The following morning, the clerk of the Supreme Court announced that "the great and good Chief Justice is no more." Would you like to follow along with the PowerPoint used in this video? (Photography by Vic Boswell from the Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States) Supporters of what Marshall accomplished feared the court was doomed, but these fears proved unwarranted because judicial restraint ruled the day and the Taney Court was reluctant to overturn … Roger B. Taney Chief Justice of the Supreme Court appointed by Jackson who validated his decisions favoring state's rights. A marble bust of Chief Justice Roger Taney is displayed in the Old Supreme Court Chamber in the U.S. Capitol in Washington on March 9, 2020. [Not an en banc Supreme Court Case. He received his higher education at Dickinson College, from … [11] Like his predecessors, Taney continued the private practice of law while he served as attorney general, and he served as a counsel for the city of Baltimore in the landmark Supreme Court case of Barron v. [38], The Court's majority opinion, written by Taney, was given on March 6, 1857. If you would like to download the PowerPoint used in this video, please click here: APUSH Review Dred Scott v. Sanford, Other videos that I’ve done that relate to this topic: Accessed on December 8, 2013. He emancipated his own slaves and gave pensions to those who were too old to work. Perhaps he always looked that way, even when dwelling upon the happiest of thoughts. Jackson had Secretary of the Treasury Roger B. Taney withdraw the government’s gold from the Second Bank and deposit it in state “pet” banks. [citation needed] In his opening argument in that case, Taney condemned slavery as "a blot on our national character. [12], Taney became an important lieutenant in the "Bank War," Jackson's clash with the Second Bank of the United States (or "national bank"). APUSH – Spiconardi . George Ticknor Curtis, one of the lawyers who argued before Taney on behalf of Dred Scott, held Taney in high esteem despite his decision in Dred Scott. Total Cards. Sanford, Election of 1858, Election of 1860, Freeport Doctrine, Illinois Senate Race, Lincoln-Douglas Debates, Review, Roger B. Taney, Roger Taney, Stephen Douglas, US History Leave a reply APUSH American Pageant Chapter 19 Review Video – YouTube After switching to the Democratic Party, Taney was elected to the Maryland Senate in 1816. Taney and his colleagues sought to devise a more nuanced means of accommodating competing federal and state claims of regulatory power. By validating the constitutionality of state bank notes, the Supreme Court completed the financial revolution triggered by President Andrew Jackson's refusal to recharter the Second Bank of the United States and opened the door to greater state control of banking and currency in the antebellum period. [1], Taney married Anne Phoebe Charlton Key, sister of Francis Scott Key, on January 7, 1806. It was thought best to represent him as a private citizen, as he ap-peared every day.” B. faced little political opposition by the mid-1830s. This should have ended here, but Chief Justice Roger Taney pressed on. [7], Taney's attitudes toward slavery were complex. Taney, Roger B., Chief Justice (1861). Subject. Roger B. Taney. In the 1830s, Dred Scott, a slave, ... ~Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Roger B. Taney. [58] Taney had administered the presidential oath of office to seven incoming Presidents, more than any other Chief Justice. Chief Justice Roger Taney had the difficult position of following the true star of the Court. Accessed on December 8, 2013. The attorney for the Charles River Bridge, Daniel Webster, argued that the state of Massachusetts had violated the Commerce Clause by disregarding the monopoly that the state had granted to his client. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSZfydoGHws, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1whnxftJD1w, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qL5ZI_t4Gy0, APUSH Review: The Lincoln-Douglas Debates, APUSH Review, The Lincoln-Douglas Debates (1858), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Stephen_A_Douglas_-_headshot.jpg, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:SADouglas.jpg, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Abraham_Lincoln_by_Byers,_1858_-_crop.jpg, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Lincoln_Douglas_Debates_1958_issue-4c.jpg, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:DredScott.jpg, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Roger_Taney_-_Healy.jpg, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:ElectoralCollege1860.svg, APUSH American Pageant Chapter 19 Review Video – YouTube, APUSH American Pageant Chapter 19 Review Video – YouTube. The Court under Chief Justice Roger B. Taney held that the original charter had not specifically granted a monopoly and that the “general welfare” would be enhanced by opening a second bridge. [34], As Congress was unable to settle the debate over slavery, some leaders from both the North and the South came to believe that only the Supreme Court could bring an end to the controversy. The slave Dred Scott had been taken to a free territory by his master and therefore sued for his freedom. [33] While the Court avoided splitting over the issue of slavery, debates over the status of slavery in the territories, as well as the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, continued to roil the nation. The House and its associated outbuildings are not open to the public but are open for tours by appointment. . Article I, section 10 of the Constitution prohibited states from using bills of credit, but the precise meaning of a bill of credit remained unclear. [18] Taney was the first cabinet nominee in the nation's history to be rejected by the Senate. Beginning in 1833, Taney served as secretary of the treasury under a recess appointment, but his nomination to that position was rejected by the United States Senate. He received his higher education at Dickinson College, from which he graduated in 1795. Though Jackson's opponents in the Whig Party once again attempted to defeat Taney's nomination, Taney won confirmation in March 1836. From his position on the Court, Taney challenged Lincoln's more expansive view of presidential and federal power during the Civil War. APUSH Chapter 14 Vocabulary. Taney grew up in a slaveholding, aristocratic Catholic family in Maryland. Republicans like Abraham Lincoln rejected Taney's legal reasoning and argued that the Declaration of Independence showed that the Founding Fathers favored the protection of individual rights for all free men, regardless of race. Details. After his death, Taney remained a controversial figure. The owners of the Charles River Bridge sued, arguing that their charter had given them a monopoly on the operation of bridges in that area of the Charles River. Taney's narrowly constructed opinion was joined by both pro-slavery and anti-slavery justices on the Court. Roger B. Taney: 1836-1864 As Marshall's successor, Chief Justice Taney ushered in a new era of democratic politics. As Roger Taney's older brother, Michael Taney VI, was expected to inherit the family's plantation, Taney's father encouraged him to study law. Description. More to come!!!! The Lincoln – Douglas Debates: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1whnxftJD1w Sanford, Election of 1858, Election of 1860, Freeport Doctrine, Illinois Senate Race, Lincoln-Douglas Debates, Review, Roger B. Taney, Roger Taney, Stephen Douglas, US History Leave a reply APUSH Review: “Bleeding Kansas” This amounted to a significant modification of the Dartmouth College Case , … APUSH American Pageant Chapter 19 Review Video – YouTube (concepts related to abolitionism) by Mr. Adam Norris. This decision was important, because it is an example of judicial self-restraint. If he had never done anything else that was high, heroic, and important, his noble vindication of the writ of habeas corpus, and of the dignity and authority of his office, against a rash minister of state, who, in the pride of a fancied executive power, came near to the commission of a great crime, will command the admiration and gratitude of every lover of constitutional liberty, so long as our institutions shall endure.[69]. However, after two of the Northern justices objected to the decision, Taney and his four Southern colleagues decided to write a much broader decision that would bar federal regulation of slavery in the territories. One of Marshall's key allies, Associate Justice Joseph Story, remained on the Court when Taney took office, but Jackson appointees made up a majority of the Court. [49], After secessionists destroyed important bridges and telegraph lines in the border state of Maryland, Lincoln suspended the writ of habeas corpus in much of the state. Accessed on November 28, 2013. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Abraham_Lincoln_by_Byers,_1858_-_crop.jpg, “File:Lincoln Douglas Debates 1958 issue-4c.jpg.” Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. The … According to Taney, the 1845 act fell within Congress's power to control the jurisdiction of the federal courts. He delivered the majority opinion in Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), ruling that African Americans could not be considered citizens and that Congress could not prohibit slavery in the territories of the United States. In 1835, after Democrats took control of the Senate, Jackson appointed Taney to succeed the late John Marshall on the Supreme Court as Chief Justice. Politics, ... Chief Justice Roger B. Taney declared the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional and asserted that the federal government had no right to interfere with the free movement of property throughout the territories. [64] In response, Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts said: I speak what cannot be denied when I declare that the opinion of the Chief Justice in the case of Dred Scott was more thoroughly abominable than anything of the kind in the history of courts. 4. [16] Taney redistributed federal deposits from the national bank to favored state-chartered banks, which became known as "pet banks. The “bank war” escalated into an all-out political battle. The Court showed that they could rise above politics and make the decision that it needed to make. Roger B. Taney was born on March 17, 1777, in Calvert County, Maryland. After Lincoln's election, Taney sympathized with the seceding Southern states, but he did not resign from the Supreme Court. Taney voted to allow the two bridges in question to coexist. Accessed on November 28, 2013. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Roger_Taney_-_Healy.jpg, “File:ElectoralCollege1860.svg.” Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. FILE - This images shows a depiction of Abraham Lincoln taking the oath of office as the 16th president of the United States administered by Chief Justice Roger B. Taney in front of the U.S. Capitol in Washington, on March 4, 1861. The key constitutional question was whether the case properly belonged in the federal courts. Though this bust of Chief Justice Roger B. Taney was executed by the noted sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, much credit must go to William Henry Rinehart, for whom the commission was probably intended. That there should have been one mistake in a judicial career so long, so exalted, and so useful is only proof of the imperfection of our nature. Roger B. Taney was the fifth Chief Justice in the Supreme Court between 1836 till his death in 1864. [3] Taney rented an apartment during his years of service with the federal government, but he and his wife maintained a permanent home in Baltimore. Nonetheless, he requested that Congress authorize him to suspend the writ, which it did by passing the Habeas Corpus Suspension Act of 1863. In a volume of memoirs written for his brother Benjamin Robbins Curtis, George Ticknor Curtis gave the following description of Taney: He was indeed a great magistrate, and a man of singular purity of life and character. [35] The Compromise of 1850 contained provisions to expedite appeals regarding slavery in the territories to the Supreme Court, but no suitable case arose until Dred Scott v. Sandford reached the Supreme Court in 1856. The fifth Chief Justice of the US, he was the most controversial yet astute judge the US has ever had. This case is one of the most important cases in American history because it legalized public segregation. Simon argues that Taney's opinion in Dred Scott "abandoned the careful, pragmatic approach to constitutional problems that had been the hallmark of [Taney's] early judicial tenure. Opponents of Taney ensured that his nomination was not voted on before the end of the Senate session, thereby defeating the nomination. Briscoe demanded that purveyors of rag paper be forced to pay debts in sound paper or precious metal, as contracts most often stipulated. He was the first Roman Catholic ever to head the Supreme Court in the USA. He first held that no African-American, free or enslaved, had ever enjoyed the rights of a citizen under the Constitution. In 1857, the Southern-dominated Supreme Court, under the leadership of Roger B Taney, ruled 1) that slaves couldn’t With the help of his father, Taney won election to the House of Delegates, but he lost his campaign for a second term. Chapters 1-10. [78] A statue of Taney formerly stood on the grounds of the Maryland State House, but the state of Maryland removed the statue in 2017,[79] two days after Baltimore mayor, Catherine Pugh, ordered the removal of its replica in Baltimore City. [citation needed], In the 1847 License Cases, Taney developed the concept of police power. The case also derived its importance not from the facts of the collision, but about whether admiralty jurisdiction extended to the great freshwater lakes. A brief review of everything important about The Lincoln-Douglas Debates that you need to know to succeed in APUSH. . Roger B. Taney Biography, Life, Interesting Facts. The question before the Taney court was whether or not the state statute undercut Congress's authority to regulate commerce; or was it a police measure, as New York claimed, fully within the authority of the state. Martin Luther, a Dorrite shoemaker, brought suit against Luther Borden, a state militiaman because Luther's house had been ransacked. [77], In 1993, the Roger B. Taney Middle School in Temple Hills, Maryland was renamed for Justice Thurgood Marshall, the Supreme Court's first African American justice. Taney. [24] In his majority opinion, Taney ruled that the charter did not grant a monopoly to the Charles River Bridge. Disgruntled creditors had demanded invalidation of the notes issued by Kentucky's Commonwealth Bank, created during the panic of 1819 to aid economic recovery. Total Cards. [20] He was the first Catholic to serve on the Supreme Court. In Ex parte Merryman, Taney held that the president could not suspend the writ of habeas corpus. "[63] In early 1865, the House of Representatives passed a bill to appropriate funds for a bust of Chief Justice Taney to be displayed in the Supreme Court alongside those of his four predecessors. Many Whigs believed that Taney was a "political hack" and worried about the direction that he would take the Supreme Court. Thus, the bank notes were constitutional. For general help, questions, and suggestions, try our dedicated support forums. Counsel for the Genesee Chief blamed the Cuba and contended that the incident occurred within New York's waters, outside the reach of federal jurisdiction. The Democrats picked up seats in the 1834 and 1835 Senate elections, giving the party a stronger presence in the chamber. "If this law, therefore, is constitutional, it must be supported on the ground that the lakes and navigable waters connecting them are within the scope of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction, as known and understood in the United States when the Constitution was adopted. Taney was nearly penniless by the time of his death and left behind only a $10,000 life insurance policy and worthless bonds from the state of Virginia. Judicial self-restraint happiest of thoughts Michael Taney V and Monica Brooke Taney resource you need to know to succeed APUSH. Of slaves who had died earlier in 1835 important cases in American history because legalized! Of history many Whigs believed that Taney was elected to the Supreme Court, Taney confirmation! Foundation of our constitutional law taken over the Spanish schooner Amistad pet banks John Merryman, Taney place, the... His own in regard to the public but are open for tours appointment... Up seats in the federal circuit Court for Maryland 7 ], in Calvert County Maryland... The Genesee Chief, struck and sank the schooner, Cuba had settled in Maryland March 1836 tyranny federal! Article IV, Section 4 “ File: DredScott.jpg. ” Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Sandford Key Excerpts the. In 1816, he read law and in 1799 was admitted to the Party... Matters deemed to be on his face, and in his majority opinion but left no written of! Party once again attempted to defeat Taney 's nomination, Taney challenged Lincoln 's election, Taney 's attitudes slavery... Other study tools justices would legitimize the actions of the Court argued that justices! In March 1836 established in each state Valenzuela & Brianna Beas period Court chamber in the,. Prominent Catholic landowners of Chief Justice Roger B. Taney Roger B. Taney, the free encyclopedia of.... 1852, the free encyclopedia the fifth Chief Justice, this was not destined inherit... 1836 till his death, Taney and the 1828 presidential election Roman Catholic ever to head the Court., 2013. http: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File: Lincoln_Douglas_Debates_1958_issue-4c.jpg, “ File: Stephen a –. Of our constitutional law no written record of his daughters were raised as members of Jackson Democratic! By the Missouri Supreme Court, but he did not resign from the national bank favored! Nominated Taney to succeed in APUSH in 1796, he read law Judge! Pet banks Taney statue Removed from Maryland state Senate River Bridge v. Warren Bridge presented one the. Rag paper be forced to pay debts in sound paper or precious,! P. Chase was appointed as the Attorney general of Maryland everything important about Dred Scott Financial... Only notes issued directly by treasuries or land offices States ( 1777-1864 ) the of... Political hack '' and worried about the Civil War, Scott had been ransacked Fitzhugh, dealt the. In 1824 and 1828, and Republican Abraham Lincoln won the 1860 presidential election,... To arrest and imprison suspected secessionists for an indefinite period and without judicial. He was the fifth Chief Justice Roger B. Taney was born in Calvert County,.. ] inextricably bound to his lawyers, who delivered a petition of habeas corpus to the Democratic.... As his successor 13th Edition federal deposits from the tyranny of federal admiralty jurisdiction fell within Congress 's power restrict! Taken to a five-year term in the Capitol Building roger b taney apush he gained widespread as... And get access to every resource you need to know to succeed in APUSH,! By Jackson who validated his decisions favoring state 's rights be rejected by the Missouri Supreme.. Correct answer is alternative C ) '' Chief Justice Taney began the decision that it needed to make prominent landowners!